DIY Accounting vs. Hiring a CPA: Which Model Actually Saves Money?
You're spending 10 hours/month doing bookkeeping in QuickBooks. That feels free. But at $40/hour effective wage, you're burning $400/month in opportunity cost. Meanwhile, a CPA costs $150-200/month. This guide does the true math: When is DIY worth it? When should you hire help? And what's the hybrid approach that works best for most makers?
The Hidden Cost of DIY
Most makers calculate DIY accounting cost as "just the software subscription = $15/month." Wrong. The real cost is your time. If you spend 10 hours/month on bookkeeping and your hourly rate is $40, DIY costs you $400/month in lost production time or opportunity cost. Now compare: DIY ($15 software + $400 time) vs. CPA ($200/month). DIY is actually 2x more expensive.
Most makers never do this math. They think free labor (theirs) is always cheaper than paid labor (accountant's). That's only true if your time has zero value—which it doesn't.
The Three Accounting Models
Model 1: DIY Accounting (You Do It All)
Cost Breakdown:
- • QuickBooks subscription: $15-30/month
- • Your time: 10-15 hours/month × $40/hour = $400-600/month
- • Tax software (at year end): $100-200
- • Total true cost: $515-830/month
Pros:
- ✓ No external fees (appears cheap)
- ✓ 100% control and visibility of all transactions
- ✓ Learn your business financial details intimately
Cons:
- ✗ Massive time commitment (10+ hours/month)
- ✗ High error risk (missed deductions, categorization mistakes)
- ✗ Errors cost more in taxes missed or audits than hiring help
- ✗ Can't delegate or scale
- ✗ Zero tax strategy (you just track, don't optimize)
Best for: Hobby businesses or ultra-simple operations (1-5 transactions/week). Anyone with <$30K annual revenue and zero employees.
Model 2: Bookkeeper / Virtual Accountant
Cost Breakdown:
- • Bookkeeper/virtual accountant: $100-300/month
- • Your time: 1-2 hours/month (reviewing, answering questions) = $40-80
- • Tax software: $100-200 (usually included)
- • Total cost: $140-350/month
Pros:
- ✓ Professional quality bookkeeping (fewer errors)
- ✓ Only 1-2 hours/month of your time (vs. 10-15 DIY)
- ✓ Cheaper than full CPA ($100-300 vs. $300-800)
- ✓ Can provide light tax advice
Cons:
- ✗ No tax strategy or optimization
- ✗ Limited advice beyond bookkeeping
- ✗ No audit support
- ✗ Less expertise than a CPA
Best for: Growing businesses ($30-100K revenue) that need cleaner books but don't need complex tax planning yet.
Model 3: CPA / Tax Professional
Cost Breakdown:
- • Full CPA service: $300-800/month
- • Your time: 0-1 hours/month = $0-40
- • Tax filing included in monthly fee
- • Total cost: $300-800/month
- • Tax savings from optimization: $2,000-5,000/year (often covers the fee 2-3x)
Pros:
- ✓ Expert-level tax strategy (saves $2,000-5,000/year)
- ✓ Audit support and representation
- ✓ Business advice beyond just accounting
- ✓ Your time: essentially zero (they handle everything)
- ✓ Scalable (same cost whether you do $50K or $500K revenue)
Cons:
- ✗ Most expensive option ($300-800/month)
- ✗ Less personal involvement/visibility into day-to-day
- ✗ Quality varies widely (need to find the right CPA)
Best for: Serious businesses ($100K+ revenue), complex structures, multiple income sources, employees, or high-stakes tax planning.
Model 4: HYBRID (Recommended) ✓
Cost Breakdown:
- • You: DIY bookkeeping using QuickBooks (3-5 hours/month)
- • Your time: 5 hours × $40 = $200
- • Annual CPA review/tax filing: $800-1,500/year ($67-125/month average)
- • Total blended cost: $267-325/month
- • Tax savings: $2,000-3,000/year (CPA review catches deductions you miss)
How It Works:
- You maintain books in QuickBooks (categorize transactions, track expenses)
- CPA reviews your books once/year before tax time
- CPA optimizes taxes, files returns, handles audit support
Pros:
- ✓ Lowest total cost ($267-325/month vs. $515+ DIY or $300-800 full CPA)
- ✓ You stay involved (understand your business)
- ✓ Professional-grade tax strategy (saves money)
- ✓ Scales with you (same cost at $50K or $300K revenue)
- ✓ Expert handles complex tax issues
Cons:
- ✗ Still requires 3-5 hours/month from you
- ✗ Need to find a CPA who offers this model (not all do)
BEST FOR MOST MAKERS: Any business growing to $50-100K+ revenue. This is the sweet spot: you maintain control, get expert tax help, and pay the least.
Decision Framework: When to Choose Each Model
| Decision Factor | DIY | Bookkeeper | Hybrid | Full CPA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Revenue | <$30K | $30-50K | $50-100K | $100K+ |
| Hourly Rate (Your Time) | <$20 | $20-30 | $30-50 | $50+ |
| Complexity | Simple | Moderate | Moderate-High | Complex |
| Employees? | No | No | Maybe | Yes |
| Multiple Revenue Sources? | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Real Cost Comparison: Sample Maker's First Year
Let's say you're a jewelry maker doing $60,000 revenue in Year 1. Your time is worth $40/hour. Here's the true cost:
DIY Accounting
Hybrid (DIY + Annual CPA Review)
The hybrid model saves $5,350/year ($6,330 DIY cost - $980 hybrid net cost) while giving you expert tax help and freeing up 5 hours/month.
How to Find the Right CPA
Look for These Qualifications:
- ✓ Experience with small business / handmade businesses
- ✓ Willing to do "hybrid" (you maintain books, they do annual review)
- ✓ Proactive about tax planning, not just filing
- ✓ Reasonable monthly fee ($150-300 for hybrid arrangement)
- ✓ Available for questions throughout the year
Questions to Ask:
- • "Do you offer hybrid bookkeeping arrangements?"
- • "What's your fee structure for a $50-100K revenue business?"
- • "What tax deductions are most makers missing?"
- • "Can you help with entity structure (LLC vs. S-Corp)?"
- • "What accounting software do you prefer?"
Let TrueCraft Handle the Bookkeeping Part
Whether you go DIY, hybrid, or full CPA, TrueCraft makes the accounting easier. Automate sales imports from Etsy/Shopify, track expenses with photos, generate P&L statements. One less thing to figure out.
Start Free