Risk Management

Insurance for Makers: Product Liability, Studio Coverage, and Compliance

A customer gets hurt using your product. A fire destroys your studio and all your tools. A shipping accident damages someone's home. These aren't hypotheticals for handmade makers—they're real risks that can cost thousands or tens of thousands of dollars to resolve. Yet most handmade makers operate without any insurance. They hope nothing bad happens. And statistically, most of the time it doesn't. But when it does, uninsured makers face devastating financial and legal consequences. This guide covers every type of insurance relevant to handmade makers, how much it costs, what it actually covers, and which types are critical versus optional. Most importantly, you'll see that insurance is far more affordable than most makers think—and not having it is a much bigger risk than having it.

The Risk: What Actually Happens If Something Goes Wrong

Let's walk through realistic scenarios that happen to handmade makers:

Scenario 1: Product Liability

A customer's child has a severe allergic reaction to dyes in your handmade textile.

Medical bills: $15,000. The parent sues for emotional distress and permanent sensitivity: $50,000 total claim.

If uninsured: You're personally liable. The judgment is against you. Your business savings, personal savings, and potentially your home equity are at risk.

If insured: Your product liability insurance covers it. You pay your deductible (typically $250-$500) and the insurance pays the rest.

Scenario 2: Property Loss

A fire in your home studio destroys $20,000 worth of equipment, supplies, and work-in-progress products.

Your homeowner's insurance typically doesn't cover business property. You're out $20,000, plus income loss while you rebuild.

With business property insurance: You're covered for the equipment and materials.

Scenario 3: Shipping Accident

Your package damages a customer's hardwood floor during delivery: $3,000 in repairs.

They sue you (the shipper/maker) instead of the shipping company. You're personally liable.

With general liability insurance: Covered.

The pattern is clear: Without insurance, each scenario costs you thousands out of pocket. With insurance, you pay a small deductible and move on.

Types of Insurance for Handmade Makers

1. Product Liability Insurance (Most Important)

What it covers: Injuries or property damage caused by defects or problems with your product.

Typical Cost

$200-$500/year

Varies by craft type and revenue

Typical Coverage

$1M-$2M per incident

Covers legal defense + damages

Real examples covered:

  • • A candle causes a house fire (defective wick)
  • • Textiles cause allergic reaction (dye contamination)
  • • Jewelry causes skin reaction (nickel allergy to materials)
  • • Cosmetics cause rashes (contamination or ingredient issue)
  • • Furniture collapses causing injury (structural defect)

Who requires it: Etsy and Shopify don't officially require it, but many payment processors and insurance partners strongly recommend it. If you sell on Amazon or through certain premium marketplaces, it's often mandatory.

Pro Tip: Get Product Liability Insurance First

If you can only afford one insurance policy, get product liability. It covers your most likely risk (product defects) and is the cheapest.

2. General Liability Insurance

What it covers: Non-product-related injuries or property damage caused by your business operations.

Typical Cost

$300-$800/year

Typical Coverage

$1M-$2M

Real examples covered:

  • • A customer trips on your studio floor (customer bodily injury)
  • • Your display knocks over and damages the customer's property
  • • A shipping accident damages someone's home (shipping liability)
  • • An employee gets hurt at your studio (covered if you have employees)

How it differs from product liability: General liability covers accidents unrelated to your product. Product liability covers defects in your product.

3. Business Property / Studio Insurance

What it covers: Your equipment, supplies, and inventory if damaged, stolen, or destroyed.

Typical Cost

$300-$1,000/year

Coverage Amount

Varies (typically $5K-$50K)

What's covered:

  • • Equipment and tools (sewing machines, kilns, jewelry equipment, etc.)
  • • Raw materials and inventory
  • • Work-in-progress products
  • • Fixtures and improvements to your studio space

Important note: Your homeowner's insurance typically does NOT cover business property. If you work from home, you need a separate business property policy.

4. Home Business Insurance / Homeowner's Rider

What it is: An endorsement/rider to your homeowner's or renter's insurance that extends coverage to your home-based business.

Typical Cost

$100-$300/year

Coverage Limits

Typically $2,500-$5,000

Who needs it: If you work from home and have homeowner's or renter's insurance, ask your agent about adding a business rider. It's cheap and provides basic protection.

Note: This typically covers lower limits ($2,500-$5,000) than a separate business policy. If your equipment is worth more, you need a separate business property policy.

5. Business Auto Insurance

Who needs it: If you use a vehicle for business (deliveries, picking up supplies, etc.), you might need commercial auto insurance instead of personal auto insurance.

Typical cost: $500-$1,500/year (depends on vehicle and usage)

Most personal auto policies exclude business use, so if you get in an accident during a business delivery, your personal insurance might not cover it.

6. Cyber Liability / Data Protection

Who needs it: If you store customer data (email addresses, payment info, etc.), you should consider cyber insurance.

Typical cost: $200-$500/year (for small businesses)

Covers data breaches, ransomware attacks, and identity theft protection costs.

Insurance Combinations: Which Do You Actually Need?

Here are common insurance combinations based on business type:

Minimum (Small Home-Based Maker)

Policies needed: Product Liability + Home Business Rider

Annual cost: ~$350-$600

Best for: Low-volume makers selling low-risk crafts from home

Standard (Growing Home-Based Maker)

Policies needed: Product Liability + General Liability + Business Property Insurance

Annual cost: ~$800-$1,500

Best for: Mid-level makers with $20K+ in equipment, selling higher-risk products (food, cosmetics, furniture)

Comprehensive (Commercial Studio or High-Risk Products)

Policies needed: Product Liability + General Liability + Business Property Insurance + Business Auto Insurance

Annual cost: ~$2,000-$4,000+

Best for: Commercial studios, food makers, larger operations with employees or multiple vehicles

The best approach: Start with product liability (cheapest and most critical). Add other coverage as your business grows and your assets increase.

What Affects Insurance Costs

Insurance premiums vary based on several factors:

1. Craft Type (Highest Impact)

Risk level varies by craft. High-risk products cost more to insure:

  • Lower risk: Jewelry, art prints, sculptures, leather goods → $200-$350/year
  • Medium risk: Textiles, furniture, candles → $300-$600/year
  • Higher risk: Food products, cosmetics, children's products → $500-$1,000+/year

2. Revenue Level

Most insurers base premiums on estimated annual revenue:

  • • $10,000-$50,000 revenue: $200-$400/year
  • • $50,000-$100,000 revenue: $400-$700/year
  • • $100,000+ revenue: $700-$1,500+/year

3. Location

Some states have higher liability costs. Premiums vary by state and can be 10-30% higher or lower depending on location.

4. Claims History

If you've had prior claims, premiums increase. No claims history = lower rates.

5. Deductible

Higher deductible ($1,000+) = lower premium. Lower deductible ($250) = higher premium.

How to Get Insurance: Step-by-Step

  1. Identify your needs: What craft do you make? How much equipment/inventory do you have? Do you work from home?
  2. Get quotes from specialty insurers: Companies like Etsy's insurance partners, Thimble, Next Insurance, and Lemonade specialize in small business insurance.
  3. Compare quotes: Get at least 3 quotes. Compare coverage amounts, deductibles, and exclusions (not just price).
  4. Check your homeowner's insurance: Ask about adding a business rider before buying separate coverage. It's often cheaper.
  5. Start with product liability: Most affordable and most important. Add other coverage later.
  6. Review annually: As your business grows, your insurance needs change. Review coverage yearly.

Common Exclusions to Watch For

  • • Intentional damage (won't cover if YOU did something wrong deliberately)
  • • Bodily injury from employees (workers comp is separate)
  • • Damage from gross negligence or willful misconduct
  • • Certain high-risk activities (some policies exclude food/cosmetics)

Insurance vs. LLC: How They Work Together

Many makers think "I'll either get insurance OR form an LLC." Actually, they serve different purposes:

Product Liability Insurance

  • ✓ Covers product-specific injuries
  • ✓ Cheap ($200-500/year)
  • ✓ Covers legal defense costs
  • ✗ Doesn't reduce taxes
  • ✗ Doesn't provide liability protection for non-product issues

LLC (Business Structure)

  • ✓ Protects personal assets from business debts
  • ✓ Provides legal legitimacy
  • ✓ Separates business and personal liability
  • ✗ Doesn't cover specific product liability (unless you also have insurance)
  • ✗ Costs $150-500/year

Best practice: Ideally, have BOTH:

  • • Product Liability Insurance covers the most common risk (product defects)
  • • LLC provides broader protection for business debts and non-product liability

If you can only choose one: Get insurance first. It covers the highest-probability risk at the lowest cost. As you scale, form an LLC for additional legal protection. See Sole Proprietor vs. LLC for more details.

What Do Etsy, Shopify, and Amazon Require?

Etsy

Official requirement: Etsy does NOT officially require insurance.

Practical reality: Etsy's payment processing partners and insurance providers strongly recommend it. If you get in a dispute or legal issue, having insurance makes resolution easier.

Shopify

Official requirement: No formal requirement, but Shopify recommends it in their legal guidance.

Amazon Handmade

Official requirement: Amazon requires product liability insurance for food products and some other high-risk categories.

Practical reality: Even where not required, having insurance protects you legally and shows professionalism.

Key Takeaways

  • Product liability insurance is cheapest and most important: $200-500/year covers the highest-probability risk (product defects).
  • Most handmade makers need 2-3 types of insurance: Product liability + general liability + property insurance (if you have >$5K in equipment).
  • Insurance is affordable: Full coverage typically $800-1,500/year for most home-based makers.
  • Start with a homeowner's rider if available. It's often the cheapest way to get basic coverage.
  • Insurance and LLC serve different purposes. Ideally have both, but if choosing one, insurance covers the most likely risk.
  • Review annually as your business grows. Your insurance needs change as revenue and assets increase.

Continue Learning About Business Protection

Manage Your Insurance and Compliance Together

Insurance policies, renewal dates, and coverage changes—it's easy to lose track. TrueCraft helps you organize insurance policies, track renewal dates, and manage your overall business protection strategy as your business grows.

Start Free