Real-Time Inventory Sync: Prevent Overselling Across Etsy, Shopify, and Your Site
You have 10 bracelets left. You sell 1 on Etsy (manually update your sheet: now 9). You sell 1 on Shopify (forget to update). You sell 1 direct (sheet says 8, reality is 7). Now a customer on Etsy buys 8 bracelets. You promised them. You don't have them. Disaster. This guide teaches you to implement real-time inventory sync so all channels see the same stock at the same moment.
The Multi-Channel Problem
Potter sells on Etsy, Shopify, and at farmers markets. She has 30 bowls in stock. An Etsy customer buys 10 (Etsy updates to 20). Shopify still shows 30 (no update). Farmers market visitor buys 15 bowls (she forgets to update anything). A Shopify customer tries to buy 25 bowls. System shows 30 available. She only has 5. Now she has an angry customer and a refund.
The Overselling Crisis
Real Example: The $800 Disaster
Timeline:
Monday 9am:
Jewelry maker has 15 custom necklaces (20+ hours each, $150 profit each).
Monday 2pm:
Etsy customer buys 5 necklaces. Etsy shows 10 left. Spreadsheet wasn't updated.
Monday 6pm:
Shopify customer buys 5 necklaces. Shopify was updated (now shows 10). But Etsy still shows 10 (they're not connected).
Tuesday 8am:
Two new orders: Etsy (8 necklaces) + Shopify (7 necklaces) = 15 total. She only has 5 left.
Cost of overselling:
- • Refund two orders: $1,050
- • Refund processing fees: $50
- • Lost profit on 15 necklaces: $2,250
- • Customer service time: 2 hours ($40 value)
- • Damage to reputation: Negative reviews on 2 platforms
- • Total: $3,390 in losses + reputation damage
Why Manual Updates Fail
1. Human Error
You sell on Etsy. You remember to update. But then direct mail orders come in. Shopify orders pile up. You get busy. Updates slip. Inventory goes out of sync.
2. Time Delay
You update Etsy at 5pm. You update Shopify at 6pm. In that one-hour window, 3 customers placed orders based on outdated inventory.
3. Scalability Problem
With 1-2 sales per day, manual updates might work. With 20+ sales across platforms, it's impossible to keep up.
4. Offline Channels
You sell at a farmers market. Cash payment. No update to any system. You return home with 3 units sold but inventory still shows full stock.
Real-Time Sync Solutions
Option 1: Platform-Native Tools (Free/Low Cost)
Etsy + Shopify Native Sync
Both platforms offer "inventory sync" if you list the same product on both. Stock updates flow both ways (usually within 15-60 minutes). Works for identical listings.
Limitations:
- • No farmers market integration
- • No connection to your own website
- • Delay of 15-60 minutes (not true real-time)
- • Only works for identical SKUs
Cost:
Free (built into Etsy/Shopify)
Option 2: Zapier/IFTTT Automation (Low Cost)
How It Works
When a sale happens on Etsy, Zapier automatically updates Google Sheets inventory. Zapier also monitors your Shopify inventory and updates Etsy. Multiple platforms talk via a central spreadsheet.
Process:
- • 1. Sale on Etsy → Zapier triggers
- • 2. Zapier reduces Google Sheets by 1 unit
- • 3. Zapier updates Shopify listing
- • 4. Shopify shows new stock (usually within 5 minutes)
Limitations:
- • Still 5-15 minute delays (not true real-time)
- • Requires manual Zapier setup (technical)
- • Can fail if APIs go down
- • No integration for offline sales
Cost:
$20-100/month (Zapier subscription)
Option 3: Dedicated Inventory Software (Best)
How It Works
Software sits in the middle. When you sell on Etsy, Shopify, direct, or offline (manual entry), all updates go to central inventory. All platforms pull from central inventory (real-time or near real-time).
Examples:
- • TrueCraft: Purpose-built for makers (real-time sync + BOMs)
- • Shopify Plus / Etsy Basic + third-party integrations
- • Lightspeed, Square for POS + online
- • TradeGecko or Skubana for wholesale
Benefits:
- • True real-time sync (seconds, not minutes)
- • Offline sales support (entry at end of day)
- • Integrated with BOM system (production depletes inventory)
- • Multi-warehouse support
- • Forecasting & reorder alerts
Cost:
$50-300+/month (enterprise) Typically $100-150/month for makers.
Choosing Your Sync Strategy
| Selling Channel(s) | Recommended Approach | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy + Shopify only | Platform-native sync | Free, simple, sufficient for 2 channels |
| Etsy + Shopify + own website | Zapier automation | Low cost, 3-5 minute sync is acceptable |
| Etsy + Shopify + Instagram Shop + offline | Dedicated software | Real-time, supports offline, manages complexity |
| Any + active farmers markets/wholesale | Dedicated software | Needs offline entry + production integration |
Best Practices for Inventory Sync
1. Set Conservative Stock Levels
If sync is 5-minute delayed and you have 10 units, show only 8 online. Buffer prevents overselling.
2. Reconcile Weekly
Even with sync, reconcile your actual physical inventory to the system weekly. Catch discrepancies early.
3. Log Offline Sales Immediately
Farmers market sale at 3pm? Log it to system at 3:15pm. Don't wait until evening.
4. Monitor Sync Health
Check that all channels are updating. Zapier failed? Etsy API down? Know when problems occur.
5. Plan for Sync Delays
If there's a 5-minute delay and you receive 10 orders/minute, you could oversell. Plan inventory levels accordingly.
Related Articles
Related Articles
You might also be interested in these related articles about artisan business management.
Linking BOM to Inventory: From Recipe to Real-Time Stock Tracking
Connect production to inventory automatically.
Explore Materials & Inventory Management
View All Articles →Real-Time Inventory Across All Channels
TrueCraft automatically syncs inventory across Etsy, Shopify, your website, and offline sales. One source of truth prevents overselling and customer disappointment.
Start Free