Tax Planning

Self-Employment Tax for Makers: The Surprising Tax Bill You Owe

Your handmade business earned $80,000 profit last year. Congratulations! Then tax season arrives. On top of federal and state income tax, you owe $12,300 in self-employment tax. Wait, what? This is the tax bill that shocks makers every year. It's not income tax—it's Social Security and Medicare tax for the self-employed. And it's due quarterly, not annually.

By Nick Jain•January 22, 2025•11 min read

The $12,000 Shock

Sarah runs a successful jewelry business. She netted $80,000 profit in 2024 and felt great about her earnings. In April 2025, her accountant gave her the tax bill: $12,300 in self-employment tax alone, plus another $18,000 in federal and state income taxes. Total: over $30,000 due.

"I didn't save anything for taxes," she said, panicking. "I thought I just paid income tax like when I had a W-2 job. What is self-employment tax? Why is it so much?"

Her accountant explained: When you're self-employed, you pay both the employee AND employer portions of Social Security and Medicare taxes. That's 15.3% on top of your regular income tax. W-2 employees only see half this tax deducted from paychecks—employers pay the other half invisibly. Self-employed makers pay both halves.

What Is Self-Employment Tax?

Self-employment tax funds Social Security and Medicare, just like FICA taxes for W-2 employees. The difference is who pays:

Employee vs Self-Employed: Who Pays What

W-2 Employee (Traditional Job)

• Employee pays: 7.65% (6.2% Social Security + 1.45% Medicare)
• Employer pays: 7.65% (invisible to you)
• Total: 15.3% paid, but you only see 7.65% deducted from paycheck
You feel: 7.65% tax burden

Self-Employed Maker

• You pay: 15.3% (12.4% Social Security + 2.9% Medicare)
• No employer to split the cost
• You pay both the employee AND employer portions
You feel: 15.3% tax burden

Translation: If you earned $80,000 as a W-2 employee, you'd pay $6,120 in FICA taxes. As a self-employed maker earning $80,000 profit, you pay $12,240. Same earnings, double the tax.

The Exact Calculation Formula

Self-employment tax is calculated on 92.35% of your net profit (not 100%). This accounts for the employer-equivalent portion deduction. Here's the step-by-step formula:

Step-by-Step Calculation

Step 1: Net Profit from Business$80,000

Step 2: Multiply by 92.35%$80,000 × 0.9235 = $73,880

Step 3: Apply 15.3% SE Tax Rate$73,880 × 0.153 = $11,304

Total Self-Employment Tax Owed:$11,304

Important Notes:

• This is ON TOP of income tax (federal and state), not instead of
• Social Security portion (12.4%) maxes out at $168,600 of income in 2024
• Medicare portion (2.9%) applies to all income with no cap
• Additional 0.9% Medicare tax kicks in above $200,000 income

Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments

Here's the kicker: You can't wait until April to pay this tax. The IRS requires quarterly estimated tax payments throughout the year. Miss these deadlines, and you pay penalties and interest—even if you file on time and pay in full in April.

Quarter	Income Period	Payment Due Date	Example Payment ($80k profit)
Q1	January 1 - March 31	April 15, 2025	$2,826
Q2	April 1 - May 31	June 15, 2025	$2,826
Q3	June 1 - August 31	September 15, 2025	$2,826
Q4	September 1 - December 31	January 15, 2026	$2,826
Annual Total			$11,304

Note: These payments cover BOTH self-employment tax AND income tax. The $2,826 example above is for SE tax only. You'll need to add estimated federal and state income tax to each quarterly payment.

Safe Harbor Rules: Avoiding Penalties

The IRS gives you two "safe harbor" options to avoid underpayment penalties. As long as you meet ONE of these thresholds, you won't owe penalties—even if your actual tax bill is higher:

Option 1: 100% of Prior Year

Pay quarterly estimated taxes equal to 100% of what you owed last year (110% if AGI over $150,000).

Example:

2024 total tax: $25,000. Pay $6,250 per quarter in 2025 ($25,000 ÷ 4). Even if you owe $35,000 in 2025, no penalty—just pay the $10,000 balance in April 2026.

Option 2: 90% of Current Year

Pay quarterly estimated taxes equal to at least 90% of what you'll owe this year.

Example:

2025 estimated tax: $35,000. Pay $7,875 per quarter ($35,000 × 0.9 ÷ 4). You're safe. Pay the final 10% ($3,500) in April 2026 with no penalty.

Which Safe Harbor Should You Use?

Use 100% of prior year if: Your income is growing significantly. You avoid guessing high and overpaying quarterly. Downside: Large balance due in April if income jumps.

Use 90% of current year if: Your income is stable or declining. You prefer to pay as you go and minimize April surprise. Downside: Requires accurate forecasting.

Most makers choose 100% of prior year for simplicity and certainty. It's the easiest to calculate and guarantees no penalties.

Underpayment Penalties: What Happens If You Don't Pay Quarterly

Skip quarterly payments and pay everything in April? The IRS charges underpayment penalties and interest. Here's how it works:

Penalty Calculation Example

Scenario: Maker owes $30,000 in total taxes for 2025

• Should have paid: $7,500 per quarter (April, June, Sept, Jan)
• Actually paid: $0 quarterly, $30,000 in April 2026
• Underpayment penalty: ~3-5% annual rate applied monthly

Estimated Penalty Breakdown:

• Q1 payment missed (12 months late): $7,500 × 4% = $300
• Q2 payment missed (10 months late): $7,500 × 3.3% = $248
• Q3 payment missed (7 months late): $7,500 × 2.3% = $173
• Q4 payment missed (3 months late): $7,500 × 1% = $75

Total Penalty: ~$796 (plus you still owe the $30,000)

Translation: You paid $796 for the privilege of delaying quarterly payments. That's money thrown away that could have gone to materials or marketing.

Monthly Savings Strategy: Never Scramble Again

The best way to handle quarterly taxes is to save monthly. This smooths out cash flow and prevents the "oh no, quarterly payment is due tomorrow" panic.

Simple Monthly Savings Formula

Step 1: Calculate Effective Tax Rate

Self-employment tax (15.3%) + Federal income tax (~15-25%) + State income tax (~5%)

Example: 15.3% + 22% + 5% = 42.3% total tax rate

Step 2: Set Aside Percentage of Each Sale

Every time revenue hits your account, immediately transfer tax percentage to savings

Example: Sell $5,000 this month → transfer $2,115 to tax savings (42.3%)

Step 3: Pay Quarterly from Savings

When April 15, June 15, Sept 15, or Jan 15 arrives, pay from your tax savings account

No scrambling, no surprises, no stress

Success Story: From Panic to Calm

After getting hit with $3,200 in underpayment penalties in 2023, pottery maker Daniel implemented a monthly savings system:

• Opened separate savings account labeled "Tax Reserve"
• Set automatic transfer: 40% of every Etsy and Shopify deposit
• By Q1 deadline (April 15, 2024), had $8,200 saved (needed $7,800)
• Paid quarterly taxes on time, zero penalties

"I sleep better knowing tax money is set aside automatically. I don't even see it as 'my money' anymore—it's the IRS's money that I'm holding temporarily."

How Deductions Reduce Self-Employment Tax

Every legitimate business deduction you claim reduces your net profit, which reduces your self-employment tax. This is powerful: deductions save you money twice—once on income tax, once on SE tax.

Deduction Impact Example

Scenario: Claim $5,000 in home office deduction

Before deduction: Net profit$80,000

Home office deduction-$5,000

After deduction: Net profit$75,000

SE tax before (15.3% of $80k)$11,304

SE tax after (15.3% of $75k)$10,597

SE Tax Savings:$707

Income Tax Savings (22% bracket):$1,100

Total Savings from $5,000 Deduction:$1,807

Translation: A $5,000 deduction saves you $1,807 in taxes. That's a 36% return on deduction value. This is why tracking deductions is critical.

Retirement Contributions That Reduce SE Tax

One of the best strategies to reduce self-employment tax is contributing to a retirement account. SEP-IRA and Solo 401(k) contributions reduce your net profit, lowering SE tax.

SEP-IRA Example

SEP-IRA allows you to contribute up to 25% of net self-employment income (after SE tax deduction), max $66,000 in 2024.

Scenario: $80,000 net profit

• Contribute $15,000 to SEP-IRA
• Adjusted net profit: $65,000
• SE tax savings: $2,121 (15.3% of $15,000, roughly)
• Income tax savings: $3,300 (22% bracket)
Total tax savings: $5,421

Bonus: You just saved $15,000 for retirement AND reduced taxes by $5,421. Win-win.

How TrueCraft Eliminates Tax Surprises

Manual tax tracking is tedious and error-prone. By the time you realize you're behind, penalties are accruing. TrueCraft automates self-employment tax calculations and quarterly payment planning.

Real-Time Self-Employment Tax Calculator

As you log sales and expenses, TrueCraft calculates your running self-employment tax liability. See exactly how much you owe today, not in April when it's too late to save.

Quarterly Payment Reminders

Never miss April 15, June 15, Sept 15, or Jan 15 deadlines. TrueCraft sends reminders 2 weeks before each due date with exact payment amounts based on safe harbor rules.

Deduction Impact Simulator

See how deductions reduce your SE tax liability in real-time. Considering a $5,000 equipment purchase? TrueCraft shows: "This saves you $765 in self-employment tax alone."

Safe Harbor Decision Tool

TrueCraft compares 100% prior year vs 90% current year and recommends which safe harbor minimizes your risk and cash flow impact based on your actual revenue trends.

Stop Getting Blindsided by Tax Bills

Self-employment tax doesn't have to be a surprise. TrueCraft calculates your quarterly obligations automatically, reminds you before deadlines, and shows exactly how much to save each month. No penalties. No panic. Just clarity.

Start Free Trial