Pricing Custom Orders: Scope Creep and Complexity Multipliers
Custom orders promise premium pricing—but without a structured approach, they become profit killers. One jewelry maker tracked 47 custom projects and found unlimited revisions inflated costs by 180% while her pricing stayed flat. Learn the frameworks that protect your margins.
The Custom Order Profit Drain
Here's what happens when artisans don't price for complexity:
- Scope Creep: "Can you also add..." requests multiply your work by 2-3× with no price adjustment
- Unlimited Revisions: Design changes consume 40-60 hours on what should be a 20-hour project
- Complexity Blindness: You charge the same for a 5-hour custom piece as a 15-hour complex design
- Material Waste: Customer-requested changes waste $200 in materials you already absorbed
Real Example: The Cost of "Just One More Change"
Sarah, a custom furniture maker, tracked a live-edge walnut dining table project:
Original Quote (Simple Custom):
| Materials (walnut, epoxy, finish) | $450 |
| Labor (40 hours @ $45/hr) | $1,800 |
| Overhead allocation (20%) | $360 |
| Total Cost | $2,610 |
| Quoted Price (40% margin) | $4,350 |
What Actually Happened:
- +Revision 1: "Can you angle the legs differently?" (+8 hours labor, $50 wasted wood)
- +Revision 2: "Actually, let's do contrasting wood inlays" (+12 hours, $180 materials)
- +Revision 3: "Can the epoxy river be wider?" (+15 hours rework, $120 additional epoxy)
| Actual Materials | $800 |
| Actual Labor (75 hours @ $45/hr) | $3,375 |
| Overhead (20%) | $835 |
| Actual Total Cost | $5,010 |
| Customer Paid (unchanged) | $4,350 |
| Sarah's Loss | -$660 |
The Lesson:
Sarah worked 75 hours and paid herself $11/hour BELOW minimum wage—on a $4,350 "premium" project. She needed a scope management system.
The Complexity Multiplier System
Instead of guessing, use this framework to adjust your base product cost based on customization difficulty:
| Complexity Level | Multiplier | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple | 1.0× | Minor personalization of existing design | Name embroidery, color swap, size adjustment |
| Moderate | 1.5× | Significant design modification with some unknowns | Custom pattern design, mixed materials, non-standard dimensions |
| Complex | 2.0× | Ground-up custom design requiring experimentation | Never-done-before techniques, structural engineering, multi-component assembly |
| Highly Complex | 2.5-3.0× | High-risk project with technical challenges and failure potential | Experimental materials, commission artwork requiring new skills, precision engineering |
How to Apply:
Step 1: Calculate your base product cost (materials + labor + overhead)
Step 2: Assess complexity level based on the table above
Step 3: Multiply: Base Cost × Complexity Multiplier = Custom Quote
Step 4: Add your desired profit margin (40-60% for custom work)
The Scope Creep Prevention Framework
Include in Base Price
- • 1-2 design concept revisions
- • Standard production updates
- • Minor adjustments pre-production
- • Quality control corrections
Charge Extra For
- • Revision #3+ (15-25% per round)
- • Design changes mid-production (impacts setup time)
- • New material requests
- • Rushed timeline compression
The Revision Cost Model:
| Revision Round | Timeline | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Revision 1-2 | Pre-production design phase | Included |
| Revision 3 | Before materials purchased | +15% project cost |
| Revision 4+ | During or post-production | +25% project cost |
| Major Redesign | Structural/concept change | Re-quote from scratch |
Pro Tip:
Track revision time religiously for 10-20 custom projects. You'll discover your actual revision costs are likely 2-3× what you estimated. Use that data to adjust your pricing model.
The Change Order System (Protect Yourself)
When a customer requests work beyond the original scope, use this process:
Document the Request
Write down exactly what the customer is asking for. Email it back: "Just to confirm, you'd like me to..."
Calculate Additional Cost
Break down the extra work: materials, labor hours, timeline impact
Additional work breakdown:
- • Additional epoxy materials: $120
- • Walnut inlay materials: $180
- • Additional labor (27 hours @ $45/hr): $1,215
- Total change order: $1,515
Present as Professional Estimate
Frame it as ensuring quality and managing expectations:
Get Written Approval
Require email or signed change order before starting additional work. No verbal agreements.
When to Say No to Custom Orders
Not every custom project is worth taking. Red flags that signal unprofitable work:
Timeline Red Flags
- • "I need this in 3 days" (your normal timeline is 3 weeks)
- • Unrealistic expectations about handmade production speed
- • No flexibility on deadline even with rush fees
Scope Red Flags
- • Vague requirements: "I'll know it when I see it"
- • Requests for skills outside your expertise
- • Complexity multiplier exceeds 3.0×
Customer Red Flags
- • Price haggling before you've even quoted
- • Comparing you to mass-produced alternatives
- • Demanding tone or excessive messaging
Financial Red Flags
- • Refuses deposit or payment terms
- • Project requires $500+ upfront material investment
- • Total quote <$300 (admin overhead eats margins)
The Polite Decline:
"Thank you for thinking of me! This project falls outside my current capabilities/timeline. I'd recommend [referral to another maker] who specializes in this type of work. Best of luck!"
Time Tracking: The Reality Check
You cannot improve what you don't measure. Track these metrics for every custom order:
Design & Communication
- • Initial consultation
- • Concept sketches
- • Revision emails
- • Approval processes
Production Time
- • Setup and prep
- • Actual making
- • Quality control
- • Finishing touches
Administrative
- • Quoting time
- • Material sourcing
- • Packaging
- • Shipping coordination
The Hidden Multiplier:
Most artisans discover their "5-hour custom project" actually consumed 12-15 hours when you include design, communication, and revisions. Track for 10 projects, then adjust your complexity multipliers based on reality.
Custom Order Pricing Quick Reference
Pricing Formula:
Base Cost = Materials + Labor + Overhead
Custom Cost = Base × Complexity Multiplier
Final Price = Custom Cost × (1 + Margin%)
Required Deposit:
• 50% deposit for all custom orders
• Non-refundable once production starts
• Balance due before shipping
Included Revisions:
• 1-2 design concept rounds
• Minor adjustments pre-production
• Quality control fixes
Additional Revision Costs:
• Revision 3: +15% project cost
• Revision 4+: +25% project cost
• Major redesign: Re-quote required
Related Articles
Related Articles
You might also be interested in these related articles about artisan business management.
The Three Pricing Models Every Artisan Should Understand
Learn cost-plus, value-based, and demand-based pricing approaches.
The True Cost of Handmade Products: Complete COGS Formula
Calculate all hidden costs before pricing custom work.
Limited Edition Pricing: Using Scarcity Psychology
Premium pricing strategies for unique, one-of-a-kind pieces.
Explore Dynamic Pricing Models
This article is part of our complete dynamic pricing strategy hub. Discover more pricing frameworks and strategies.
View All Pricing Articles →Track Custom Order Profitability
TrueCraft automatically tracks time and costs for custom orders. Know your real margins before you quote.
Start Free