Legal Compliance & Business Structure for Handmade Makers
You've built a profitable handmade business on Etsy or Shopify. But are you operating legally? Without the right business structure, licenses, insurance, and compliance measures, one lawsuit, tax audit, or platform ban could wipe out everything you've built. This complete guide covers everything you need to know about keeping your business protected and compliant.
Business Structure: Sole Proprietor, LLC, or S-Corp?
Your first legal decision: How do you want to structure your business? Most handmade makers start as sole proprietors by default—you make stuff, you sell it, you're done. But as your business grows, a more formal structure like an LLC offers liability protection and potential tax benefits.
Three Options:
- Sole Proprietor - You and your business are one legal entity. Easy to start, zero paperwork. But personal liability if sued.
- LLC (Limited Liability Company) - Separate legal entity that protects personal assets. More paperwork, annual fees ($50-$500 depending on state).
- S-Corp - Most complex, but offers tax savings if you earn $60K+/year. Requires payroll processing and quarterly filings.
Learn the full comparison in Sole Proprietor vs. LLC: Liability, Taxes, and Which Makes Sense for You.
Licenses, Permits, and Registration
What licenses do you actually need? The answer depends on your location, business structure, and craft type. A candle maker might need fire safety permits. A food maker needs health department approval. A jewelry maker selling precious metals might need assay certification.
Common requirements:
- • Business License - Required in most states/counties
- • Seller's Permit - If you collect sales tax (Etsy/Shopify does this for you in most cases)
- • EIN (Employer ID Number) - Free, required if you're an LLC or have employees
- • Craft-Specific Permits - Food, cosmetics, textiles, jewelry, furniture, etc.
See Business Licenses and Permits: What You Actually Need for state-by-state guidance.
Insurance: What You Actually Need
One customer gets hurt using your product. One shipment gets damaged. One studio fire destroys everything. Without insurance, these aren't just expensive—they're business-ending. Yet most handmade makers operate with zero coverage.
Product Liability Insurance
Covers customer injuries from defective products. ~$200-500/year for most makers. Essential.
Required by: Etsy, Shopify, Amazon
Studio/Property Insurance
Covers theft, damage, fire in your workspace. ~$300-800/year. Critical if you work from home.
Recommended for: All makers
Detailed guidance in Insurance for Makers: Product Liability, Studio Coverage, and Compliance.
Contracts, IP Rights, and Non-Competes
When do you need written agreements? When you hire contractors, work with suppliers, take custom orders, or have employees. A simple written contract prevents misunderstandings that turn into expensive disputes.
Key Agreements to Have:
- Contractor Agreement - If you hire helpers or outsource work
- Custom Order Contract - Scope, timeline, payment terms, revisions
- Supplier Agreement - Payment terms, exclusivity, quality standards
- NDA (Non-Disclosure Agreement) - If you're sharing proprietary recipes or processes
- Work-for-Hire Agreement - If others design or create parts of your products
Full guidance in Contracts 101: When You Need a Written Agreement.
Craft-Specific Regulatory Compliance
Different crafts have different regulations. Handmade food requires FDA compliance. Cosmetics need ingredient disclosure. Textiles need lead and phthalate testing. Jewelry requires hallmarking standards. Failure to comply means hefty fines or forced shutdown.
Compliance by Craft Type
- Food Products - FDA regulations, state kitchen licensing, allergen labeling
- Cosmetics & Bath Products - FDA disclosure, ingredient testing, claims validation
- Textiles & Finished Goods - Lead paint testing, phthalate limits, care labeling
- Jewelry - Precious metal hallmarking, purity standards, gemstone disclosure
- Furniture & Upholstered Items - Safety standards, flame retardant compliance, labeling
- Candles & Wax Products - Burn testing, fragrance disclosure, container safety
Deep dives for each craft type in the Regulatory Compliance cluster articles below.
Explore Clusters 16 & 17: Legal & Compliance
Cluster 16: Business Structure & Legal Basics
Master the fundamentals of legal business setup, protection, and agreements for your handmade operation.
Cluster 17: Regulatory Compliance by Craft
Craft-specific compliance requirements and regulatory frameworks for different types of handmade products.
Get Legal Compliance on Autopilot
Legal and compliance requirements vary by state, craft type, and business structure. What works for a jewelry maker in New York doesn't work for a food maker in California. TrueCraft's compliance tracker helps you stay current with filing deadlines, permit renewals, and regulatory changes—so you can focus on making.
Start Free